The Challenge of Peers with Limited Leadership Experience



Much like in sport, effective leadership in athletic departments is a cornerstone of success. Director-level positions come with a unique set of responsibilities that extend beyond expertise in sports. However, it’s not uncommon to encounter peers at this level who may possess immense sports knowledge but have limited leadership experience.

While it’s not exclusive to director-level, that’s where I’ve been operating for some time and want to explore the challenges associated with this scenario and then offer practical solutions to foster growth and collaboration within your athletic department. Each of these can also be modified to be used no matter the level of employee.

1. Acknowledge the Challenge: The first step in addressing this issue is recognition. Understand that your peers may be excellent in their specific fields but may require support and development in leadership roles.

2. Mentorship Programs: Establishing mentorship programs within the athletic department can be highly beneficial. Pair experienced leaders with those in need of guidance to provide ongoing support and knowledge transfer.

3. Leadership Training: Invest in leadership training programs or workshops that specifically address the needs of director-level staff. These programs can provide valuable insights into effective leadership strategies.

4. Encourage Self-Reflection: Encourage your peers to engage in self-reflection. Self-awareness is a fundamental aspect of leadership development. Encourage them to identify areas for improvement and set personal goals.

5. Foster a Learning Culture: Create an environment that values continuous learning. Encourage open discussions about leadership challenges and successes, allowing peers to learn from one another.

6. Lead by Example: As an experienced leader, lead by example. Demonstrate effective leadership qualities in your interactions with colleagues, providing a model for them to emulate.

7. Clear Communication: Effective communication is essential in leadership. Encourage transparent and open communication within the department, ensuring that all voices are heard and valued.

8. Provide Constructive Feedback: Offer constructive feedback when necessary. Be diplomatic and solution-focused in your approach, emphasizing growth rather than criticism.

9. Set Expectations: Clearly define expectations for director-level positions, outlining not only job-specific responsibilities but also leadership expectations. This helps peers understand their roles more comprehensively.

10. Patience and Support: Recognize that leadership development takes time. Be patient and provide ongoing support as your peers grow into their roles.

Navigating the challenge of director-level athletic peers with limited leadership experience can be both rewarding and challenging. By implementing these strategies, you can help your colleagues develop into effective leaders who contribute positively to the success of your athletic department. Ultimately, fostering a culture of growth and collaboration will benefit not only the individual directors but also the entire organization and the student-athletes it serves.

Subscribe to newsletter