Leading through Challenges: Navigating Difficult Employees in the High-Stakes World of College Athletics



In athletics, we all want to win, but we rarely tackle the hard stuff. So today’s blog is a topic that’s as crucial as a game-winning strategy: dealing with difficult employees. In the fast-paced, cut-throat industry we’re in, challenges are par for the course. But with a clear playbook and a little empathy, we can steer our teams through the storm of challenging personalities while maintaining the integrity and excellence that define college athletics.

Understanding the Cut-Throat Environment

Having spent years in the trenches of college athletics as a player and a coach, I’ve come to appreciate the intensity of this world. The stakes are high, and competition is fierce. But here’s the twist – when dealing with difficult employees, it’s vital to remember that everyone plays a part in our shared success. While we’re typically judged solely on wins and losses, we can foster a culture of success by having the tough conversations that contribute to our collective growth.

Communication: The Cornerstone of Resolution

In a high-stakes industry, open and honest communication becomes your most potent weapon. Difficult employees often bring their own set of challenges, but addressing issues head-on can transform obstacles into opportunities. Listen actively, empathize genuinely, and express your concerns clearly. By engaging in constructive dialogues, you create an environment where concerns are voiced and addressed, leading to better understanding and mutual respect.

Tailoring Leadership Approaches: One Size Doesn’t Fit All

The cut-throat world of college athletics demands that we adapt swiftly, and the same applies to managing difficult employees. Each individual comes with their own motivations and struggles, so embrace the art of tailoring your leadership approach. Recognize their strengths, understand their weaknesses, and craft strategies that uplift their performance. Just as a coach tweaks tactics for different opponents, customize your approach to get the best out of your department members.

Accountability and Consequences: Upholding Standards

With a championship culture, maintaining high standards is non-negotiable. When faced with difficult employees, holding them accountable is essential for the integrity of your team. Clearly define expectations, provide necessary resources, and set benchmarks for improvement. If progress isn’t made, ensure that consequences are both fair and reasonable. This not only preserves the team’s excellence but also sends a message about the culture you uphold.

Mentorship and Development: Nurturing Growth

Difficult employees often possess untapped potential waiting to be discovered. In the competitive world of college athletics, fostering growth is essential for long-term success. Transform your role into that of a mentor, guiding them towards improvement and personal development. Provide opportunities for skill enhancement, offer constructive feedback, and celebrate milestones. By investing in their growth, you not only elevate their performance but also contribute to the team’s overall success.

Self-Care and Leading by Example: A Balanced Approach

Leading in a high-stakes environment can take a toll on anyone, including supervisors. Amidst the challenges of managing difficult employees, don’t forget to prioritize self-care. We used to joke about not “smoking your turkey” because once you fizzle out, your performance declines. Your well-being directly influences your leadership effectiveness. Model a balanced approach to your team, showcasing the importance of resilience, self-awareness, and maintaining a healthy work-life balance.

In the pressure cooker of college athletics, the journey isn’t always smooth sailing, especially when dealing with difficult employees. However, by embracing open communication, adapting leadership approaches, upholding standards, nurturing growth, and caring for oneself, supervisors can navigate the choppy waters with finesse.

Subscribe to newsletter